Share

What the Milburn Report means for schools, colleges and young people

The publication of Alan Milburn’s final review into young people and work places the growing number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) at the centre of the national education debate.

The report, From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation, sets out a ten-year ambition to reduce the UK’s NEET rate from around 13 per cent to five per cent by 2036 and help an additional 600,000 young people into education, employment or training each year.

Among its headline recommendations are the creation of a new Youth Opportunity Serice in every part of England, new legal guarantees to support young people into education, training or work, greater support for parents, a target for 90 per cent of children to be school-ready by age five, and a curriculum rebalanced towards skills and employment.

At the heart of the review is the argument that youth disengagement cannot be tacked through isolated interventions alone. Instead, it calls for what Milburn describes as a “complete system reset”, bringing together education, health, employment and welfare services around the needs of young people.

For school leaders, that recognition may prove to be one of the report’s most signficant conclusions. Many of the recommendations stem from the belief that the factors leading to disengagement often emerge years before a young person leaves education, requiring earlier intervention and more coordinated support.

Schools cannot solve this alone

Responding to the review, Paul Whiteman, general secretary of school leaders’ union NAHT, welcomed the report’s recognition that the factors behind disengagement often emerge years before a young person leaves education. He said:

“It is positive that this review has recognised that issues which lead to young people disengaging in education, training and work do not appear overnight. The factors which can place children at risk often emerge much earlier and require support long before they reach the point of leaving school.

“Helping children thrive starts well before children enter the classroom, and schools alone cannot address the social, economic and health challenges that can affect attendance, engagement and achievement. It is therefore encouraging to see a recognition that improving outcomes for young people requires coordinated action across government and public services.

“Setting children on the right path starts in the earliest years. The experiences, routines and learning children develop at home, in early years settings and throughout primary school, lay the foundations for their confidence, wellbeing and future success.

“Since the pandemic, school leaders have noticed increasing issues with children’s school readiness, including around speech and language development, and the aim of addressing this is welcome. NAHT has been vocal on the need for more investment in tackling challenges facing families and their children so they do not harm young people’s ability to attend and flourish in school, and the review’s call for more support for parents should be heeded.”

The Education Endowment Foundation (EEF) also welcomed the report’s recognition that tackling the NEET challenge requires action beyond the classroom.

Professor Becky Francis CBE, chief executive of the EEF, said:

“Young people from disadvantaged backgrounds are far more likely to become disconnected from education and employment. Closing the attainment gap is one of the most effective ways to change that trajectory, but schools and colleges cannot tackle this challenge alone.

“The Milburn Review is right to recognise that improving long-term outcomes for young people requires a multi-faceted approach across all areas of society, including in health, wellbeing, and the welfare system.”

What this means

For years, schools have argued that NEET figures are often the end result of challenges that begin much earlier. This includes:

  • attendance concerns
  • unmet SEND needs
  • speech and language delays
  • poor mental health
  • family hardship
  • lack of access to support services

Milburn’s focus on school readiness and early intervention suggests the review is attempting to move the conversation away from crisis management and towards prevention.

The challenge, however, will be whether government can deliver the long-term investment required. School leaders are likely to welcome the diagnosis. However, they may question whether the resources needed to address these issues will follow.

Is the curriculum preparing young people for life beyond school?

Another major theme of the review is the belief that education should prepare young people not only for examinations, but for employment and adult life.

On this point, Paul Whiteman said:

“We welcome the recognition that young people should have an education system which prepares them not only for exams, but for adult life, further study and employment. NAHT has long supported a broad and balanced curriculum, alongside greater parity of esteem between academic, vocational and technical pathways, so that every young person can pursue a route that reflects their talents, strengths and aspirations. The government’s plans to offer greater choice when it comes to vocational and technical education, and truly recognise their value, will be vital in helping to create high-quality pathways for young people.”

This may prove one of the most politically significant aspects of the report.

Successive governments have promised greater parity between academic and vocational routes. Yet many employers, colleges and education leaders continue to argue that technical education remains viewed as a secondary pathway rather than an equally valuable destination.

The review appears to acknowledge a difficult reality. Some young people disengage because they struggle to see the relevance of their education to their future lives. Creating stronger links between learning and employment could help address that issue. However, this will only happen if high-quality vocational opportunities genuinely carry the same status and progression routes as traditional academic qualifications.

A new Youth Opportunity Service

The proposed Youth Opportunity Service is one of the report’s flagship recommendations.

NAHT has cautiously welcomed the proposal, while highlighting the risks of introducing another layer of responsibility without sufficient support.

Paul Whiteman said:

“The proposed Youth Opportunity Service could play an important role in bringing together support across education, employment, health and wider services, but it must provide additional capacity and coordination, rather than simply creating new expectations or responsibilities for schools.

“As ministers consider the recommendations in this review, they must ensure that schools and colleges have the time, capacity and funding needed to deliver change successfully, especially given the sheer amount of reform they are already contending with. Any new expectations must be matched by the support necessary to make them achievable.”

The EEF also highlighted the importance of better data sharing and earlier identification of young people at risk of disengagement.

Professor Becky Francis said:

“The report is also right to highlight the importance of better data and earlier identification of young people at risk of disengagement. More joined-up information across education and public services would help support young people through key transitions, give colleges a clearer understanding of learners’ needs, and strengthen the evidence needed to evaluate what works.”

The Health Foundation also highlighted the role health services will need to play if the reforms are to succeed.

Alison Ismail, director of health and inequalities at the Health Foundation, said:

“Today’s report from Alan Milburn sets out a potentially transformational package of support for young people who are not earning or learning. But a working state must also be a healthy state, so it is essential that the government now invests in the health and other support set out in the report to turn this vision into reality and break decades of failure for young people.

“As the review recognises, no credible strategy to improve young people’s participation can succeed without addressing health-related barriers to work and education head-on. Almost half of young people out of work and education report work-limiting health conditions, but too many opportunities to identify problems early and offer support are missed. This must change, with a more ambitious and proactive role for public services, including the NHS, alongside prioritising mental health support in schools and communities. The proposed Youth Opportunity Service could be central to achieving this shift.

“The Milburn review rightly provides a vision for a fundamentally different welfare system where young people with health conditions are quickly helped into education or work. However, it will be vital that ministers back the review’s recommendation that support is firmly in place before any existing benefits are withdrawn, and that the new system is designed to reflect young people’s needs. This will be essential to avoid pushing more young people into poverty and worsening their health.”

The concept appears attractive on paper. One of the longstanding criticisms of support for vulnerable young people is that education, health, employment and social services often operate independently rather than collaboratively.

Yet history suggests that structural reform alone rarely solves systemic problems. The success of any Youth Opportunity Service is likely to depend less on its title and more on whether agencies genuinely share responsibility, information and resources.

Are the reforms ambitious enough?

Not everyone believes the proposals go far enough.

The Social Market Foundation also responded to the review. It welcomed many of the recommendations while warning that the scale of the challenge may require further action.

Dani Payne, head of education and social mobility at the think tank, said:

“Milburn is right: we cannot expect young people to climb a career ladder when the first rung is missing. Too many are being asked for experience no one will give them, while the support they need arrives only after they have already fallen out of education or work.

“Many of the review’s proposals, including previous SMF recommendations such as job guarantees for young people, are promising. Milburn’s target to reduce our NEET rate to five per cent by 2036 is highly ambitious – and rightly so. But even if adopted in full, the package of support is unlikely to be enough on its own, underlining just how much work lies ahead for Government to turn the tide on youth inactivity.

“And Government should importantly not just seek to get young people into any job – they should also have regard for the quality of those opportunities. As our recent research found, the extent to which your first job provides support and builds your confidence is associated with lasting career impacts into someone’s later career.”

The EEF also welcomed the report’s focus on colleges and post-16 education, while warning that additional expectations must be matched by appropriate support.

Professor Becky Francis said:

“Educational disadvantage doesn’t end at 16, and neither should the support available to address it. It’s welcome to see recognition of the important role colleges play in supporting young people who are at risk of becoming disconnected from education and employment.

“However, the scale of the challenge means sustained investment and support will be needed if colleges are to meet growing demand and help more young people succeed.”

This criticism gets to the heart of the debate.

Most education leaders would agree that reducing the number of young people who are NEET is an important goal. The more difficult question is whether success should be measured solely by getting young people into work, education or training, or by ensuring those opportunities are meaningful, sustainable and suited to their aspirations.

The review appears to recognise that disengagement is rarely caused by a single factor. But if the government is serious about reaching its ambitious target, policymakers may have to go even further than Milburn’s recommendations and confront wider issues around poverty, mental health, regional inequality and access to opportunity.

The bigger picture

Perhaps the most significant aspect of the Milburn Review is not any individual recommendation, but its apparent rejection of the idea that young people become disengaged overnight.

Instead, the report seems to argue that youth opportunity is shaped by a chain of experiences stretching from the early years through primary school, secondary education and beyond.

If ministers accept that premise, the review could mark a significant shift in how government approaches the NEET challenge. The question now is whether that recognition will be matched by the long-term funding, policy stability and cross-government collaboration needed to turn ambition into reality.

Further Commentary

Added at 2pm on Tuesday, 17 November.

Confederation of School Trusts chief executive, Leora Cruddas CBE, said:

“We welcome the final report on Young People and Work. Alan Milburn is right to celebrate schools and “outstanding teachers”, and we welcome the systemic analysis that shows success in school remains central to future life chances.

“We are much more cautious about the recommendation that primary schools should start using risk of NEET indicator tools. The best thing that we can do is focus on ensuring that more children can read and write to an expected standard.

“We are also concerned about proposal to hold schools to account for ‘work readiness.’ We should be cautious of over-emphasising the role of schools and underplaying the economic arguments around the number of young people not in education, employment or training.

“We look forward to working with the government to shape an evidence-informed response to this important report.”

Mark Russell, chief executive of The Children’s Society, said:  

“It is a national scandal that one million young people are not earning or learning, I welcome the Milburn Review and it must lead to the radical change we need to back young people.

“There is no single reason why young people find themselves out of education or work. They face different challenges, from a lack of opportunity to difficulties that can be left unaddressed for years.  For too long, support has been fragmented. We welcome the review’s call for joined up, locally led systems that give young people the support they need. 

“But if the system only picks young people up once they’re out of education, employment or training, it’s stepping in too late. Early support can transform young people’s futures, and it pays for itself, too. Our research with PBE found that every £1 invested in children and teenagers’ mental health support, delivers £14 in economic benefits.  

“With a ringfenced prevention budget now promised, the Government has an opportunity to act. Investing in Early Support Hubs in every area would give young people somewhere to go for help with their mental health and other difficulties, to get support before problems take hold.

“I believe in young people, and in their talents and energy.  We have let far too many of them down and this is a moment that calls for radical change, our young people deserve nothing less.”

Suzanne Moss, RHS director of learning, said:

“Horticulture is a green industry and a growth industry. Supported in the right way, we can unlock thousands of green jobs and new opportunities for young people, who we know are passionate about the environment and health. 

“Our apprenticeship scheme sees on average 3,000 per cent more applicants than we can accommodate, the majority of which are under 24. In response we’ve introduced more than 500 new annual work experience opportunities, internships, taster days and summer studentships to unlock barriers to formal training or a permanent position. We’re also excited to be piloting a new RHS Level 1 qualification for schools in recognition that not everyone will have the experience to jump straight into a Level 2 qualification, and to open up a horticultural career to a wider network. Based on the Milburn Review’s recommendations we would welcome foundation apprenticeships being made available to the land based sector and would look to use our expertise to coordinate improved apprenticeship take up within the large number of SMEs in the sector.

“We agree with the review that we must provide more opportunities for young people. At its most basic, access means experience and understanding. We look forward to growing our work to ensure that every young person has the chance to engage with nature, to understand the contribution they might make, and to have the opportunity to bring their talents to the sector.”

Michelle Leeson, managing director for employment, justice, and health at the Growth Company, said:

“The Milburn Review rightly recognises that young people need more than just access to vacancies. They need local, tailored support that helps them gain real on-the-job experience and navigate what can often be a complicated employment and skills system and challenging labour market.

“We also welcome the review’s recommendation to expand flexi-job opportunities for disabled young people. Flexible, accessible routes into work can help remove barriers, open up new opportunities, and make sure young people are able to fulfil their potential and move into long-term employment.”

You may also like...